When a newborn requires surgery due to a birth injury, families face overwhelming medical decisions while simultaneously questioning whether the injury could have been prevented. Florida law permits parents to pursue medical malpractice claims when healthcare providers fail to meet the applicable standard of care during labor and delivery, resulting in injuries that require surgical intervention.
Severe birth trauma affects nearly 5 per 1,000 newborns, according to BMJ Open (2018). Some of these injuries heal with time and therapy, while others require surgical correction. Understanding your legal rights in these situations can help your family secure the resources necessary for your child’s long-term care.
What Birth Injuries Commonly Require Surgical Intervention?
Not every birth injury requires surgery, but certain types of trauma sustained during delivery may necessitate operative intervention when conservative treatments prove inadequate. The severity of the injury, the structures affected, and the timing of intervention all influence whether surgery becomes necessary.
Brachial Plexus Injuries Requiring Nerve Surgery
Brachial plexus injuries occur when the network of nerves controlling arm movement becomes stretched, compressed, or torn during delivery. According to the Journal of Pediatric Orthopaedics (2024), these injuries affect approximately 0.9 to 1.1 per 1,000 live births in the United States.
While many brachial plexus injuries improve with physical therapy, Paediatrics & Child Health (2021) reports that 20-30% of affected infants do not recover fully. When nerve damage is severe, surgical options include nerve grafts, nerve transfers, and muscle or tendon repairs. The optimal window for these procedures typically falls between 4 and 9 months of age.
Brain Injuries and Intracranial Procedures
Hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy (HIE) represents one of the most serious birth injuries. According to Medscape’s clinical overview (2024), HIE affects approximately 1-3 per 1,000 live births in developed countries. When oxygen deprivation leads to intracranial bleeding, blood clots, or hydrocephalus, neurosurgical intervention may become necessary.
The PMC/NIH review (2011) found that 40-60% of infants with HIE die by age 2 or have severe disabilities including cerebral palsy and epilepsy. Therapeutic hypothermia, when administered within 6 hours of birth, can reduce mortality and disability by approximately 25%, according to the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews (2013).
Skull Fractures and Cephalohematoma Treatment
Instrument-assisted deliveries carry significantly elevated trauma risks. BMJ Open (2018) documented that forceps delivery results in birth trauma at a rate of 25.48 per 1,000 births, compared to just 4.74 per 1,000 for spontaneous vaginal delivery—representing a nearly five-fold increase in trauma risk.
When delivery instruments cause skull fractures or large blood collections beneath the scalp (cephalohematoma), surgical drainage through burr hole procedures or craniotomy may be required to relieve dangerous intracranial pressure.
When Conservative Treatment Fails
Surgery typically becomes necessary when non-operative approaches fail to resolve the injury. The following birth injuries may ultimately require surgical intervention:
- Torn or avulsed brachial plexus nerves unresponsive to therapy
- Intracranial hemorrhages causing dangerous pressure buildup
- Hydrocephalus requiring shunt placement
- Severe shoulder dystocia injuries with permanent nerve damage
- Depressed skull fractures requiring elevation
- Spinal cord injuries from traumatic delivery
What Must You Prove to File a Birth Injury Lawsuit in Florida?
Call us today at (305) 694-2676 or
contact us online for a free case evaluation.
Hablamos español.
Florida medical malpractice claims require proving four essential elements. As established in Wale v. Barnes, 278 So. 2d 601 (Fla. 1973), plaintiffs must demonstrate the standard of care, breach of that standard, proximate causation, and damages. The failure to prove any single element defeats the claim.
Establishing the Standard of Care
Under Fla. Stat. § 766.102(1), the standard of care is defined as “that level of care, skill, and treatment which, in light of all relevant surrounding circumstances, is recognized as acceptable and appropriate by reasonably prudent similar health care providers.” Florida holds specialists to a specialist standard when practicing within their specialty and has largely abandoned the traditional locality rule in favor of a national professional standard for clinical care.
Proving the Provider Breached That Standard
Breach occurs when a healthcare provider’s conduct falls below the prevailing professional standard. Under Fla. Stat. § 766.102(2), for affirmative medical intervention, breach requires showing the injury was not within the necessary or reasonably foreseeable results of the procedure when performed according to the standard of care.
In birth injury cases, breach might include failing to recognize fetal distress, delaying a necessary cesarean section, using excessive force during delivery, or improperly employing forceps or vacuum extractors. Florida’s cesarean section rate of 36.2%, according to the Florida Department of Health (2023), reflects clinical decisions that must be weighed against the standard of care when injuries occur.
Demonstrating Causation Under Florida Law
Florida requires plaintiffs to establish factual causation under the “more likely than not” standard, meaning greater than 50% probability that the defendant’s negligence caused the injury. This requirement was established in Gooding v. University Hospital Building, Inc., 445 So. 2d 1015 (Fla. 1984), which also rejected the “loss of chance” doctrine.
Causation in birth injury cases can be complex. The American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology (2008) found that only 14.5% of cerebral palsy cases are associated with intrapartum asphyxia. This statistic underscores why expert testimony is essential—plaintiffs must prove that the specific birth injury resulted from the provider’s negligence rather than from unrelated causes.
Documenting Damages From Surgical Injuries
Birth injuries requiring surgery typically involve substantial damages. Your claim must document both the immediate surgical costs and the long-term consequences of the injury. Expert testimony from life care planners and economists often becomes necessary to project future medical needs and lost earning capacity.
A valid Florida birth injury claim requires proving these four elements:
- The applicable standard of care that governed the provider’s conduct
- A breach of that standard through action or omission
- Proximate causation linking the breach to your child’s injury
- Documented damages including surgical costs, ongoing care, and pain and suffering
Who Can Be Held Liable for Birth Injuries Requiring Surgery?
Multiple parties may bear responsibility for birth injuries depending on who provided care and the employment relationships involved. Florida law recognizes several theories of liability that may apply to hospitals, physicians, and other healthcare providers.
Obstetricians and Delivery Room Physicians
The attending obstetrician typically bears primary responsibility for delivery decisions. Under Fla. Stat. § 766.102(5)(a), expert witnesses testifying against specialists must specialize in the same specialty and have devoted professional time during the three years immediately preceding the incident to active clinical practice in that specialty.
Shoulder dystocia cases illustrate the physician’s critical role. According to the American Academy of Family Physicians (2004), brachial plexus palsies occur in 4-15% of shoulder dystocia cases, though fewer than 10% result in permanent injury. The physician’s management of this emergency directly affects outcomes.
Hospital Liability Under Florida Law
Florida hospitals may face liability under multiple theories established in Irving v. Doctors Hospital of Lake Worth, Inc., 415 So. 2d 55 (Fla. 4th DCA 1982). These include respondeat superior for employed physicians, apparent agency when the hospital holds out an independent contractor as its agent, and nondelegable duty for certain core functions.
Under Fla. Stat. § 766.110, hospitals have direct obligations regarding staff selection, risk management, and supervision. When hospital policies, staffing decisions, or equipment failures contribute to a birth injury, the facility itself may be named as a defendant alongside individual providers.
Nurses and Other Medical Staff
Labor and delivery nurses play crucial roles in monitoring fetal heart rate patterns and alerting physicians to signs of distress. Under Fla. Stat. § 766.102(6), qualified physicians may testify about the standard of care applicable to nurses and other support staff.
The “borrowed servant” doctrine may shift liability between the hospital and physician depending on who exercised control over the nurse’s specific actions during delivery. Per Roessler v. Novak, 858 So. 2d 1158 (Fla. 2d DCA 2003), these employment relationships significantly impact which parties may be held responsible.
What Are the Deadlines for Filing a Birth Injury Lawsuit in Florida?
Florida imposes strict time limits on medical malpractice claims that families must understand. Missing these deadlines can permanently bar your right to seek compensation, regardless of how severe your child’s injuries may be.
The Two-Year Statute of Limitations
Under Fla. Stat. § 95.11(5)(c), a medical malpractice action must be commenced within two years from when the incident occurred or within two years from when the incident is discovered or should have been discovered with due diligence. The discovery rule, as modified by Tanner v. Hartog, 618 So. 2d 177 (Fla. 1993), requires knowledge of the injury and a “reasonable possibility that the injury was caused by medical malpractice.”
The Four-Year Statute of Repose
Florida law imposes an absolute outer limit of four years from the date of the incident, regardless of when the injury was discovered. This statute of repose, upheld in Kush v. Lloyd, 616 So. 2d 415 (Fla. 1992), can bar claims even when the injury was impossible to discover within that timeframe.
Special Rules for Minors
Critically, the four-year statute of repose does not bar an action brought on behalf of a minor if the lawsuit is filed on or before the child’s eighth birthday. This exception provides additional time for families whose infants suffered birth injuries, but it does not eliminate time constraints entirely. Parents should not delay seeking legal consultation simply because their child is young.
In cases involving fraud, concealment, or intentional misrepresentation that prevented discovery, the period may extend to two years from discovery but cannot exceed seven years from the incident. This seven-year cap also does not apply to minors’ claims filed before their eighth birthday.
What Damages Can Families Recover?
Get started with your complimentary case evaluation today;
call us at (305) 694-2676 or reach us online using our
secure contact form.
Birth injuries requiring surgery often result in extensive damages spanning your child’s lifetime. Florida law permits recovery of both economic and non-economic damages, and following two landmark Florida Supreme Court decisions, statutory caps on non-economic damages in medical malpractice cases are currently unenforceable.
Economic Damages for Surgical Care
Economic damages encompass all quantifiable financial losses resulting from the birth injury. These include past and future medical expenses such as surgical costs, hospitalizations, medications, physical therapy, occupational therapy, and adaptive equipment. Lost earning capacity represents another major component when the injury will affect your child’s ability to work as an adult.
Non-Economic Damages After McCall and Kalitan
In Estate of McCall v. United States, 134 So. 3d 894 (Fla. 2014), the Florida Supreme Court struck down statutory caps on wrongful death non-economic damages as violating the Equal Protection Clause. North Broward Hospital District v. Kalitan, 219 So. 3d 49 (Fla. 2017), extended this holding to all medical malpractice claims.
As a result, Florida currently has no enforceable caps on non-economic damages in medical malpractice cases. Families may recover damages for physical pain and suffering, mental anguish, disfigurement, loss of enjoyment of life, and loss of consortium without statutory limitations.
Recoverable damages in Florida birth injury cases include:
- Past and future medical expenses including surgeries, therapies, and medications
- Lost earning capacity over your child’s lifetime
- Physical pain and suffering endured by your child
- Mental anguish and emotional distress
- Loss of enjoyment of life
- Parents’ loss of consortium and companionship
Wrongful Death Claims and Limitations
If a birth injury results in death, Florida’s Wrongful Death Act governs who can recover damages and what types of damages may be available. Because eligibility and damages depend on the survivors and the specific facts, families should get case-specific legal guidance as early as possible.
What Steps Must You Take Before Filing Suit?
Florida imposes mandatory pre-suit requirements that must be satisfied before filing a medical malpractice complaint. Failure to comply with these requirements can result in dismissal of your case and potential sanctions.
The Pre-Suit Investigation Requirement
Under Fla. Stat. § 766.203, before initiating litigation, the claimant must complete a pre-suit investigation to ascertain that there are reasonable grounds to believe the defendant was negligent and that such negligence resulted in injury to the claimant. This investigation must be completed before serving the Notice of Intent.
Expert Witness Affidavit Requirements
Florida law requires obtaining a verified written medical expert opinion corroborating that reasonable grounds exist to support the claim. This expert must satisfy the qualification requirements of Fla. Stat. § 766.102(5), including same-specialty matching for specialists. The expert affidavit must be submitted when the Notice of Intent is mailed.
The 90-Day Notice Period
Under Fla. Stat. § 766.106, written notice of intent to initiate litigation must be served by certified mail upon each prospective defendant at least 90 days before filing suit. Per Boyd v. Becker, 627 So. 2d 481 (Fla. 1993), this 90-day period is measured from the date notice is received by prospective defendants, not the date mailed.
The pre-suit process requires compliance with these mandatory steps:
- Conduct a thorough pre-suit investigation of potential claims
- Obtain a verified expert opinion corroborating the claim before mailing notice
- Serve Notice of Intent on all prospective defendants via certified mail
- Include copies of medical records relied upon by the expert
- Wait 90 days for defendant response before filing suit
This 90-day pre-suit investigation period tolls the statute of limitations under Hankey v. Yarian, 755 So. 2d 93 (Fla. 2000), ensuring claimants retain the full benefit of their original statutory time period.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long do I have to file a birth injury lawsuit in Florida?
Florida generally requires medical malpractice claims to be filed within two years of discovery and no later than four years from the incident. However, claims on behalf of minors may be filed until the child’s eighth birthday. Because pre-suit requirements take several months to complete, families should consult with an attorney as soon as they suspect malpractice occurred.
Does my baby needing surgery automatically mean malpractice occurred?
No. Some birth injuries occur despite appropriate medical care due to inherent risks of delivery or factors beyond anyone’s control. Under Fla. Stat. § 766.102(3)(b), a medical injury alone does not create an inference of negligence. An expert must evaluate whether the standard of care was breached and whether that breach caused the injury requiring surgery.
Can I sue if my baby’s birth injury was caused by forceps or vacuum extraction?
Potentially. While these instruments are appropriate tools when used correctly, improper application can cause serious injuries. Birth trauma occurs at significantly higher rates with instrument-assisted delivery. If an expert determines the instruments were used inappropriately or when a cesarean section should have been performed instead, a claim may be viable.
What if I cannot afford an expert witness for my case?
Medical malpractice attorneys typically work on contingency fee arrangements, meaning they advance the costs of expert witnesses and other litigation expenses. The attorney is only paid if the case results in a recovery. This arrangement makes expert testimony accessible to families who could not otherwise afford the substantial costs of pursuing a birth injury claim.
Will NICA affect my ability to file a lawsuit?
Florida’s Birth-Related Neurological Injury Compensation Association (NICA) provides no-fault compensation for certain qualifying birth injuries. If a claim qualifies under NICA, families may receive compensation through that program rather than through litigation. However, NICA has specific eligibility requirements, and many birth injuries requiring surgery do not qualify. An attorney can help determine whether NICA applies to your situation.
Taking Action for Your Child’s Birth Injury
When your newborn requires surgery due to a birth injury, understanding your legal rights becomes essential to securing the resources your child needs. Florida law provides families with the ability to pursue compensation when healthcare providers fail to meet the applicable standard of care, but strict procedural requirements and time limits govern these claims.
The four essential elements—standard of care, breach, causation, and damages—must each be proven through qualified expert testimony. Florida’s pre-suit requirements add complexity, requiring a thorough investigation, expert affidavit, and 90-day notice period before any lawsuit can be filed. Meanwhile, the statute of limitations continues to run, making timely action critical.
If your baby has suffered a birth injury requiring surgery and you believe medical negligence may have contributed, contact Prosper Injury Attorneys to discuss your situation.
