Skip to Content
Home » Blog » Who is Liable for an Accident with a Commercial Truck in Florida


Who is Liable for an Accident with a Commercial Truck in Florida

on  Truck Accidents

Accidents involving commercial trucks can be devastating, often resulting in severe injuries, property damage, and even fatalities. In Miami and across South Florida, where heavy traffic and busy highways are common, the risk of a collision with a large truck is a genuine concern for many drivers. 

If you or a loved one has been injured in a commercial truck accident in Florida, you may not know who is liable for the incident and how to seek the compensation you deserve. Identifying all liable parties is key when seeking maximum compensation. While at first glance, the truck driver may seem to be the one to blame, in reality, the trucking company could also share liability. 

Sometimes, commercial trucking companies try to avoid liability for accidents by classifying their drivers as independent contractors rather than employees. This tactic can complicate the process of determining who is responsible for the damages caused by the accident, as independent contractors are generally considered to be self-employed and responsible for their own actions. However, federal regulations have made it clear that companies leasing trucks and drivers are still responsible for the operation of the equipment and any accidents that occur during the lease period, regardless of the driver’s classification. 

For these reasons, you should hire an experienced Florida truck accident lawyer to thoroughly investigate the relationship between the driver and the trucking company, uncover any attempts to misclassify drivers and hold all liable parties accountable for their negligence or wrongdoing.

The Complexity of Commercial Truck Accident Liability

Determining liability in a commercial truck accident is often more complex than in a typical car crash. This is because multiple parties may be involved, including:

1. The truck driver

2. The trucking company

3. The truck manufacturer

4. The cargo loader or shipper

5. Third-party maintenance providers

To establish liability, your commercial truck accident attorney must thoroughly investigate the accident’s circumstances, gather evidence, and consult with accident recreation experts. This process may involve reviewing driver logs, maintenance records, and cargo manifests, as well as interviewing witnesses and analyzing physical evidence from the scene. By identifying all potentially liable parties, your attorney can help you seek the maximum compensation for your injuries and damages, holding those responsible accountable for their actions or negligence.

Truck Driver Liability 

The truck driver is often the first party to be examined when determining liability in a commercial truck accident. Drivers are responsible for operating their vehicles safely, following traffic laws, and adhering to federal regulations set by the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA). If a driver’s negligence or reckless behavior contributed to the accident, they may be liable for damages and injuries. 

Distracted Driving

One of the most common forms of truck driver negligence is distracted driving. In today’s world of smartphones and advanced technology, it’s easy for truck drivers to become distracted by texting, checking emails, or even adjusting navigation devices. However, taking one’s eyes off the road for even a few seconds can have catastrophic consequences when operating a large commercial truck. 

Driving Under the Influence

Another major concern is driving under the influence of drugs or alcohol. Commercial truck drivers are held to a higher standard than regular motorists when it comes to impaired driving, with a lower blood alcohol concentration (BAC) limit of 0.04% compared to 0.08% for non-commercial drivers. Drivers who violate this limit or operate their vehicles while under the influence of illegal drugs or prescription medications that impair their ability to drive safely can be held liable for any accidents they cause.

Speeding and Reckless Driving

Speeding and failing to adjust to weather conditions are also common factors in truck accidents. Due to their size and weight, commercial trucks require longer stopping distances and are more difficult to maneuver than smaller vehicles. Drivers who fail to account for these factors by speeding or not adjusting their driving to adverse weather conditions, such as rain, snow, or ice, can be found negligent in the event of an accident.

Driving Fatigued

Violating hours-of-service regulations is another serious form of driver negligence. These regulations, set by the FMCSA, limit the amount of time a driver can spend behind the wheel without rest to prevent fatigue-related accidents. Drivers who exceed these limits or fail to keep accurate logs of their driving hours can be held liable for accidents caused by their fatigue or drowsiness.

It’s important to note that even if the truck driver’s actions were the primary cause of the accident, other parties may still share some responsibility. For example, if the trucking company pressured the driver to meet unrealistic deadlines or failed to maintain the vehicle properly, they may be found partially liable. Similarly, if a manufacturing defect or improperly loaded cargo contributed to the accident, the manufacturer or cargo loader may also be held responsible.

The Trucking Company’s Responsibility

The trucking company that employs the driver can also be held liable for accidents in many cases. This is because companies have a legal obligation to ensure their drivers are qualified, well-trained, and follow safety regulations. They must also maintain their vehicles in proper working order and ensure cargo is loaded and secured correctly. Trucking companies may be found liable if they:

Inadequately Trained Truck Drivers

In addition to hiring qualified drivers, trucking companies must also provide adequate training and supervision. This includes ensuring that drivers are properly trained on the specific equipment they will be operating, as well as on safe driving practices and compliance with federal regulations. Companies that neglect to provide this training or fail to supervise their drivers can be found liable for accidents resulting from driver error or negligence.

Violating FMCSA Regulations

Another way trucking companies may be liable is if they encourage or pressure their drivers to violate hours-of-service regulations or engage in unsafe practices to meet deadlines. These regulations are in place to prevent driver fatigue, which can be a significant contributing factor in truck accidents. When a trucking company prioritizes profits over safety by pushing its drivers to exceed these limits or engage in dangerous practices, it can be liable for any resulting accidents.

Improper Maintenance

Proper maintenance and inspection of vehicles is another crucial responsibility of trucking companies. Large commercial trucks require regular maintenance to ensure that they are in safe working order, and companies must keep detailed records of these maintenance activities. Failure to perform necessary maintenance or inspect vehicles regularly can lead to accidents caused by mechanical failures, such as brake malfunctions or tire blowouts. 

Some trucking companies may attempt to avoid liability by classifying their drivers as independent contractors rather than employees. However, federal regulations have made it clear that this tactic does not absolve companies of their responsibility for the operation of the equipment and any accidents that occur during the lease period. Companies that lease trucks and drivers are still considered responsible for ensuring the safety and compliance of their operations.

Manufacturer Liability After a Commercial Truck Accident

This is known as a product liability claim, which is based on the principle that manufacturers have a responsibility to ensure that their products are safe and free from defects that could cause harm to consumers.

One common example of a manufacturing defect that can lead to truck accidents is faulty brakes or steering systems. Large commercial trucks rely on complex braking and steering systems to control and stop safely, especially when carrying heavy loads. If these systems fail due to a manufacturing defect, the driver may lose control of the vehicle, leading to a serious accident. Similarly, defective tires prone to blowouts can cause trucks to swerve or roll over, putting the driver and other motorists at risk.

Malfunctioning lights or safety equipment can also contribute to truck accidents. Commercial trucks must have certain safety features, such as reflective tape, lights, and warning systems, to ensure they are visible to other drivers and can operate safely in low-light conditions. If these features fail due to a manufacturing defect, it can increase the risk of accidents, particularly at night or in poor weather conditions.

Improperly designed or manufactured cargo restraint systems can also lead to serious and deadly commercial trucking accidents in Florida. Commercial trucks often carry large, heavy loads that must be properly secured to prevent shifting or falling off the vehicle during transport. If the cargo restraint systems are defective or inadequate, the load can become unstable, making the truck difficult to control.

If a manufacturing defect is found to have contributed to a commercial truck accident, the injured party may be able to seek compensation through a product liability claim. In these cases, the manufacturer can be held strictly liable for any damages caused by the defective product, regardless of whether they were aware of the defect or not. This means that the injured party does not have to prove that the manufacturer was negligent, only that the product was defective and that the defect caused the accident and resulting injuries.

To pursue a product liability claim, it is essential to work with an experienced attorney who can investigate the accident, gather evidence, and consult with experts to determine whether a manufacturing defect was involved. This may involve analyzing the truck’s wreckage, reviewing design and manufacturing records, and consulting with engineers or other experts who can identify potential defects.

Truck Cargo Loaders and Shipper Liability 

Cargo loaders and shippers play a critical role in ensuring the safe transport of goods on commercial trucks. These companies are responsible for properly loading and securing cargo in accordance with federal regulations and industry standards. When cargo is not loaded or secured correctly, it can lead to serious accidents on the road.

One of the primary ways cargo loaders and shippers can be held liable for truck accidents is through improper loading. This can occur when cargo is distributed unevenly throughout the trailer, causing the truck to become unbalanced and more difficult to control. Uneven weight distribution can also cause the truck to tip over, especially when navigating turns or in high wind conditions.

Overloading is another common issue that can lead to accidents. Each commercial truck has a maximum weight limit that must be adhered to for safe operation. When cargo loaders or shippers exceed this limit, it can strain the truck’s tires, brakes, and suspension system, increasing the risk of mechanical failures and accidents. Overloaded trucks also require longer stopping distances, making it more difficult for drivers to avoid collisions in emergencies.

Improperly secured cargo is another major concern. Federal regulations require that cargo be secured using approved devices and methods to prevent shifting or falling off the vehicle during transport. When cargo is not secured correctly, it can shift suddenly during acceleration, braking, or turning, causing the truck to become unstable and potentially leading to rollover accidents. Loose cargo can also fall off the truck entirely, creating hazards for other vehicles on the road.

To prevent these serious truck accidents, cargo loaders and shippers must follow strict guidelines for loading and securing cargo. This includes ensuring that the cargo’s weight is evenly distributed, using appropriate tie-down devices and methods, and not exceeding the truck’s maximum weight limit. Companies that fail to follow these guidelines can be held liable for any trucking accidents that result from their negligence.

Third-Party Truck Maintenance Providers

Third-party maintenance providers play a significant role in ensuring the safety and roadworthiness of commercial trucks. Many trucking companies outsource their vehicle maintenance and repairs to these specialized service providers to ensure their fleet is maintained correctly and compliant with federal regulations. However, when these providers fail to perform their duties adequately, it can lead to serious accidents on the road.

Trucking companies are legally required to maintain their vehicles in safe operating conditions. This includes regular inspections, maintenance, and repairs of all critical components, such as brakes, tires, lights, and steering systems. When a trucking company outsources these responsibilities to a third-party maintenance provider, it is essentially entrusting the safety of its vehicles and drivers to that provider.

If a third-party maintenance provider fails to perform their duties properly, and an accident occurs as a result, they may be held liable for the resulting damages. This can occur in several ways, such as:

  • Negligent or improper repairs: If a maintenance provider fails to repair a vehicle properly or uses substandard parts or techniques, it can lead to mechanical failures on the road. For example, if a provider fails to repair a truck’s brakes properly, it could result in a catastrophic brake failure and subsequent accident.
  • Failure to identify or address safety issues: Maintenance providers are expected to inspect vehicles and identify potential safety issues. If a provider fails to notice or address a critical safety problem, such as worn tires or faulty steering components, it can contribute to an accident.
  • Inadequate or improper maintenance: Regular maintenance is essential for operating commercial trucks safely. If a maintenance provider fails to perform scheduled maintenance tasks, such as oil changes, tire rotations, or brake inspections, it can lead to premature wear and tear on critical components, increasing the risk of failures and accidents.
  • Improper documentation or communication: Maintenance providers must keep detailed records of all repairs and maintenance performed on each vehicle. If a provider does not document their work properly or communicate critical information to the trucking company, it can lead to confusion and potentially overlooked safety issues.

If a commercial truck accident in Florida is caused by negligent maintenance or repairs, both the trucking company and the third-party maintenance provider may be held liable. The trucking company has a responsibility to ensure that its vehicles are properly maintained, even if it outsources the work to a third party. It must exercise due diligence in selecting a reputable and qualified maintenance provider and regularly monitor its work to ensure compliance with safety standards.

Contact Our Florida Truck Accident Attorneys Today

Determining liability in a commercial truck accident can be a complex and challenging process. Multiple parties may be involved, and each case’s unique circumstances will dictate who is ultimately responsible for the damages. 

Call our law firm immediately if you have been injured in a truck accident in Miami or anywhere in Florida. Our attorneys will thoroughly investigate your case, identify all liable parties, and fight for the compensation you deserve.

At Prosper Shaked Accident Injury Attorneys, PA., our injury legal team is dedicated to helping truck accident victims in South Florida seek justice and recover from their injuries. We understand the physical, emotional, and financial toll these accidents can take on individuals and families, and we are here to support you every step of the way.

If you or a loved one has been involved in a commercial truck accident, contact us today for a free consultation. Call (305) 694-2676 today. Let us use our experience and expertise to help you secure the compensation you need to move forward with your life.